Ok. From what I am gathering from the different posts is some shoppers think I made a mistake and others see my point. I have been doing mystery shops for over a year and this is the first one that was rejected. I will learn from this and move on. However, no standing on my head and spinning around. (LOL). I would definitely break something!
I have learned this the hard way. Don't think logically. Do what is required of you.
Since they replied that a reshop was not needed, I would ask them to issue me a statement that the report was not going to be used in any way.