Isaiah:
1st I am sorry you had your ID Stolen.
Now to clear up some misconceptions.
A credit card is the safest as you are only liable for $50 i fraudulent charges which most Credit Card Companies (Banks) will not charge you.
A debit card is is almost as safe as a credit card in that most banks will reverse any claimed fradulent charge right away and investigate. Yes there are a few who will wait and investigate first before reversing fraudulent charges. Now the risk is in if the bank decides nope the charges were not fraudulent then your out money on a debit card where a credit card you can refuse to pay and fight them as fraudulent.
Cash is still king and the only risk with cash is someone robs you.
I would also like to point out is using a debit or credit card online is safer than at a store or merchant or bank atm or gas pump. Skimmers are out there and easy to purchase. Do you see where your card goes when you hand it to waitress at a restaurant. It i quite easy for her to skim it then run it for your check and give you your card back with you none the wiser. Then there is the weekly security breach we see. You know this store data was hacked one week and another store the next.
Lastly The unfortunate thing about Identity theft is it is no longer how do I prevent it but rather how long before it happens to you. This does not mean don't take measures to protect yourself like shredding stuff with your name and ssn and never ever write a check.
Shopping Western NY, Northeast and Central PA, and parts of Ohio and West Virginia. Have car will travel anywhere if the monies right.