@purpleicee You are so right. An editor once gave me an 8 and said I need to do a better job of paying attention. I was like what the heck does that mean. She said the report said it was a Chevron shop and I clicked on the Texaco button further down in the survey. The editor said if I had put the correct information, thet I would've earned a 10.
At first I thought I was losing my mind because that was my last stop of the day and I knew it was a Texaco. The receipt did say Chevron, but in the report I included pictures of the canopy, the MiD, and fuel pump and anyone could tell it was all Texaco branding. They should've reached out to me before closing it to find out if I had uploaded the correct pictures or get a clarification.
After doing a little digging, I noticed that this station previously was a Chevron, but they had changed it to a Texaco. I told the editor that I had no control over what was on the receipt, since the owners did not bother to correct it. I told her if she looked at the pics I submitted in the report, then it was clear that it was a Texaco gas station.
I also asked them to correct the grade to a 10 since I did not make an error. They said it was too late. Once the grade is submitted it is over. So I am held accountable for the editor's mistakes too?
I did a series of Electronic Mystery Shops and mostly given 10s. One location had an employee that was rude, clearly did not want to be there, and was deficient in her product knowledge. I gave them a low score and the editor gave me an 8. Like others have said, do they want an honest account of how the shop went or do they want a false report that says everything is spectacular and the associate has all the answers.
I reached out to one editor that consistently gave me 8s for tips on how I could improve my score. I was amazed by this person's spelling and grammatical errors. That editor was apparently from the other side of the pond or down under I think @purpleicee is spot on about needing consistency across the board from these editors.