It turns out, the issue was with the post office. The check made it to my mailbox in January.
With Honny, it's definitely the post office, LOL. I was at the PO mailing something to Honny (I forgot to tell her about it) and it didn't come up in the computer as a known address. I really thought they had fixed that. Let me know if you get it, Honny.
I hate getting paper checks in the mail. I prefer DD whenever possible and PayPal as a secondary option.